Aileen McHarg: 50 Problematic Cases – A Comment

Aileen McHarg: 50 Problematic Cases – A Comment

Any list of ‘problematic’ cases is bound to be controversial.  There are several reasons why this is so. First, as the editors acknowledge in their introductory essay, there are different ways in which cases might be problematic: They may contain bold or unexpected...
Simon Lee: A Problematic Manifesto?

Simon Lee: A Problematic Manifesto?

Only a couple of my own Top 10 problematic cases made the Judicial Power Project Top 50. So is it the judges who are problematic or the critics or just me? For all the fun of this list, it is salutary to wonder if our praise or criticism of a judgment or judge tells...